- Riho--October 2, 2019 in Washington, DC. on
Dynamite. Riho defeated Nyla Rose to become the inaugural
- Nyla Rose--February 12, 2020 in Cedar Park,
Texas. The match took place on Dynamite.
- Hikaru Shida--May 23, 2020 in Jacksonville,
Florida. The match was a no dq/no count-out match.
- Dr. Britt Baker, DMD--May 30, 2021 in Jacksonville,
Florida. The match took place at Double or Nothing.
- Thunder Rosa--March 16, 2022 in San Antonio,
Texas. The match was a cage match on Dynamite.
- Toni Storm (Interim)--September 4, 2022 in Chicago,
Illinois. She won a four-way match at All Out to become
interim champion after Thunder Rosa was previously injured.
- Jamie Hayter--November 19, 2022 in Newark, New
Jersey. The match took place at Full Gear.
- Toni Storm--May 28, 2023 in Las Vegas, Nevada.
The match took place at Double or Nothing.
- Saraya--August 28, 2023 in London, England. The
match was a four way match between Saraya, Storm, Dr. Britt
Baker DMD and Hikaru Shida at All In.